Newburgh, NY 12550, USA

Pretty Rotten Sweets

Spooky, decadent treats baked fresh for celebrations and sweet cravings

Order Something Wickedly Sweet

Services

Make it wickedly sweet

Choose your perfect treat

Stuffed Cookie Boxes

I bake fresh stuffed cookies in customizable assorted boxes for gifts, parties, and sweet cravings.

Custom Celebration Cakes

I create made-to-order specialty and custom cakes with personalized flavors, fillings, and decorations.

Gourmet Cupcakes

I make classic and specialty cupcakes, including indulgent filled and decorated flavors for celebrations.

Homemade Cheesecakes

I prepare rich, homemade cheesecakes in seasonal and decadent flavors for gatherings or special treats.

About

Sweet with a twist

I’m Lucy, the baker behind Pretty Rotten Sweets in the Hudson Valley. I create stuffed cookies, decadent cheesecakes, specialty cupcakes, and custom cakes for birthdays, holidays, gatherings, and everyday cravings. My treats are made from scratch with rich flavors, creative designs, and a playful dark edge. I love turning your ideas into desserts that feel personal, memorable, and anything but boring.

Lucy Santiago-Nixon

247
Newburgh, NY 12550, USA

Frequently Asked Questions

Contact

Let's Create Something Sweet

Tell me what you're craving, and I'll get back to you about your order.